<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=2119418688374700&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">

4 Factors that Impact Your Workers’ Compensation Premiums

May 2nd, 2018

3 min. read

By McClone

Factors_that_Impact_Workers_Comp_Premiums

Unless you’re self-employed without any other employees, every business is required by law to have workers’ compensation (work comp) insurance. This important regulation helps protect the livelihoods and well-being of workers in the event of injuries sustained on the job. Employers can expect significant consequences for noncompliance and to be fined for each day they are without coverage until it’s obtained or reinstated.

There are four major factors that impact how much your work comp premiums will be, and proactively addressing each of them can help bring costs down over time. Let’s take a look at all four along with some insights into how you can leverage each in your organization.

Experience Modification Factor

The Experience Mod, as it’s often called, is a factor calculated by the state or the National Council of Compensation Insurance (NCCI) based on your organization’s claim history. This complex calculation involves a certain threshold of losses over time that is used to determine a company’s performance or “experience.” The industry average is set at 1.0 — if your calculated factor goes above that, you can expect your work comp premiums to increase. You can, however, be rated lower than 1.0 (e.g., 0.9, 0.8, etc.) and be rewarded for your good “experience” in the form of a discount. For every point your company goes over 1.0 (e.g., 1.1, 1.2, etc.), you can expect to pay as much as 10% more in premiums.

Payroll 

The size of a company’s payroll and how its employees are classified directly impacts work comp premiums. To ensure accuracy, every company is required to complete and return a workers compensation payroll audit a few months after their policy renews or be subject to an audit non-compliance penalty charge.

If the audit reveals that your payroll was actually higher than you originally reported, you’ll be required to immediately pay the additional work comp premium that should have been charged for that higher exposure. This can be a major burden on a company’s cash flow. On the contrary, overestimating payroll will result in a premium refund after the audit. While this sounds appealing, it’s much better to have access to that money throughout the year when it’s needed most.

Injury Prevention

One of the greatest ways to improve your experience mod and lower premiums is by decreasing the number and severity of your worker’ comp claims. No matter what type of business you run, you should have a safety program, policies and procedures in place to help prevent injuries.

The range and types of programs vary greatly depending on your industry, and can include:

  • Heavy lifting protocols
  • Tool box talks
  • Slip and fall prevention
  • Forklift training
  • Ergonomics (e.g., proper monitor height, standing desks, adjustable office chairs, etc.)
  • Safety committees and audits
  • Wellness programs
  • Alcohol, tobacco and drug counseling

Safety Checklist for Construction Jobsites CTA2

Claim Management

But what happens if a claim does occur? Are there ways to mitigate the potential impact? Properly managing claims makes a big difference. For example, if a worker is injured and can return to work within three days, the impact on the Experience Mod will be considerably lower than if he or she takes an entire week off. If the worker is unable to return to normal duties within three days, assigning lighter tasks or office work until he or she is fully recovered is encouraged.

An absence of more than three days due to an injury ends up having a full impact on the Experience Mod, impacting your workers compensation premium. Work with the employee and his or her doctor to help determine appropriate return-to-work duties and timing. Also work with your broker who can help manage claims and may be able to help develop training protocols, especially for new employees who don’t know how to operate machinery properly.

Tips for Choosing a Work Comp Insurance Carrier

The insurance company you choose can help or hinder your efforts. Some carriers specialize in certain industries, such as agriculture, construction, manufacturing, food service, etc., and can provide better resources and guidance. Ask if the carrier has in-house claims adjusters. Those that do will have more on the line; they generally manage claims more effectively and care more about positive outcomes. Sometimes smaller regional carriers are a better fit for small and mid-sized companies because they can provide more personalized service and offer more safety resources.

Tips for Choosing a Work Comp Insurance Broker

When looking for a broker, work with one that represents several carriers and can recommend the best fit for your industry. A good broker will also make sure your business is coded properly with the state to ensure you’re paying the correct rates. For example, a sewer and water company typically has a greater risk and higher premiums than a standard plumbing business, but one or the other is often coded improperly. They can also recommend and work with an insurance carrier that has a team of loss control advisors to provide additional safety training and help identify areas of improvement for higher risk industries.

Most companies don’t have risk managers on staff. At McClone, our brokers serve as advisors to fill the gap, provide recommendations and work with your business to help ensure the safety of your employees and mitigate the risks of rising work comp premiums. There are many more benefits of working with an experienced broker that can help identify additional savings and opportunities to reduce risks. Take a moment to see the results of our process on one company's approach to reducing workers compensation premiums or reach out to us today to schedule a meeting to discuss your unique challenges.

Work Comp Cost Containment Guide CTA1

McClone

What is a Waiver of Subrogation for Work Comp? Are there Risks?

May 20th, 2025|4 min. read

Your Experience MOD Factor Explained

April 28th, 2025|5 min. read
Closed sign

Does your cyber insurance cover contingent business interruption?

October 25th, 2023|2 min. read
Padlock on top of computer chip pathways

Playing Defense Against Fund Transfer Fraud and Social Engineering Attacks

September 7th, 2023|2 min. read
Paperwork being shared across a desk

3 factors businesses can control in a hardening insurance market

June 28th, 2023|2 min. read
Hardening Market Insurance Premium Increase Chart

Insurance Insights: How a Hardening Market Impacts You

January 6th, 2021|2 min. read

Learning from a Crisis: 5 Steps to Boost Business Success

June 24th, 2020|2 min. read
Is_Workers’_Compensation_the_Same_in_Every_State

Is Workers’ Compensation the Same in Every State? How Wisconsin Compares

June 11th, 2020|2 min. read
Circuit board with security lock

Cybersecurity is a Team Effort and Everyone Plays Defense

January 15th, 2020|4 min. read
umbrella-1588167_1920

How High Should My Commercial Umbrella Limit Be?

May 29th, 2019|2 min. read
Top View of Boot on the trail with the text Safety First2

Safety Program: Internal Audits and Self-Inspections

May 8th, 2019|3 min. read
Under construction, helmet and bricks for building site-1

How to Avoid Common Compliance Oversights in Construction Contracts

March 20th, 2019|3 min. read
8 Must-Have Types of Insurance for Construction Companies

8 Must-Have Types of Insurance for Construction Companies

January 9th, 2019|4 min. read
Safety_Walkaround

3 Steps for Conducting an Effective Safety Walkaround

November 7th, 2018|2 min. read
Learn facts about business interruption insurance

What You Might Not Know About Business Interruption Insurance

August 15th, 2018|4 min. read
Importance_of_a_Business_Continuity_Plan

Importance of a Business Continuity Plan — Top 5 Best Practices

July 11th, 2018|3 min. read
Top_Business_Risks

Top 5 Business Risks for 2018 (And What to Do About Them)

July 3rd, 2018|2 min. read
Finding_the_Right_Insurance_Coverage

Finding the Right Insurance Coverage for Your Business

May 30th, 2018|3 min. read
caution-wet-floor-sign

The Top 10 Property & Liability Claims for Small Businesses

April 20th, 2015|2 min. read
cows-in-feild-at-dairy-farm

Dairy Margin Protection Program (MPP)

October 15th, 2014|2 min. read
wheat-feild-in-front-of-blue-sky

Important Changes to Replant Requirements

May 12th, 2014|1 min. read
money

The Insurance behind the Billion Dollar Bracket

March 19th, 2014|1 min. read
wheat-feild-in-front-of-blue-sky

GRP and GRIP Policy Changes

September 10th, 2013|2 min. read
tractor-pulling-farming-equipment-across-field

Implements of Husbandry

June 27th, 2013|3 min. read